How do Taxes Hurt Small Businesses? A Call for Reform in the Beauty Industry

Small businesses are the backbone of the American economy, driving innovation, fostering community growth, and employing nearly half of the nation’s workforce. Among these enterprises, hair salons and barbershops play a significant role in providing essential services and creating local jobs.

However, despite their contributions, these small businesses face challenges that hinder their growth—chief among them being unfair tax burdens. This article delves into how current tax policies affect hair salons and barbershops, offering insights and tips for stakeholders and advocating for necessary reforms.

The Vital Role of Hair Salons and Barbershops in Job Creation

Hair salons and barbershops are more than just places to get a haircut; they are community hubs that:

• Create Local Employment: Offering jobs close to where people live, reducing commute times, and supporting local economies.
• Provide Competitive Wages: Stylists and barbers often earn around $28 per hour, including tips, making the profession financially rewarding.
• Offer Career Advancement: Many establishments promote from within, allowing stylists to advance to managerial positions based on performance.
• Support Flexible Work Arrangements: Catering to both full-time and part-time employees, accommodating various lifestyles and commitments.

These businesses also provide valuable benefits to their employees, such as:

• Paid Time Off: Enhancing work-life balance and employee satisfaction.
• Retirement Plans with Employer Match: Encouraging long-term financial planning.
• Subsidized Health Benefits: Making healthcare more accessible and affordable.
• Flexible Schedules: Allowing employees to tailor their work hours to personal needs.

The Unfair Tax Burden on Small Beauty Businesses

Despite their positive impact, hair salons and barbershops face a significant tax challenge. Under the current federal tax code, these businesses are required to pay Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) taxes on the tips their employees receive. This policy means that businesses are taxed on income they never actually receive, as tips are a direct transaction between the customer and the stylist.

For small businesses operating on thin margins, this tax burden can be substantial. For example, a salon with multiple locations might pay over $282,000 annually in FICA taxes on employee tips alone. This amount could represent the revenue from the first few thousand haircuts each year, significantly impacting the business’s bottom line.

The Impact of the Tax Burden on Growth and Investment

The high tax obligations limit small businesses’ ability to reinvest in their operations and workforce. The funds spent on FICA taxes for employee tips could otherwise be used to:

• Increase Employee Pay: Offering higher wages to attract and retain top talent.
• Hire Additional Staff: Reducing employee workload and improving customer service.
• Enhance Employee Benefits: Introducing perks like maternity/paternity leave or additional health benefits.
• Expand Business Operations: Opening new locations and creating more jobs.
• Stabilize Service Prices: Mitigating the need for price increases due to inflation.

By diverting these funds to federal taxes, small businesses lose opportunities to grow and support their local communities.

The Restaurant Industry Comparison: A Case for Fairness

The disparity becomes more apparent when comparing the beauty industry to the restaurant sector. Over thirty years ago, Congress recognized the unfairness of taxing restaurants on employee tips and provided a tax credit for the FICA taxes paid on those tips. This credit acknowledged that tips are income earned by employees, not the business, and helped alleviate the financial strain on restaurants.

However, hair salons and barbershops were excluded from this relief. Despite operating under similar circumstances—employees receiving tips directly from customers—these businesses continue to bear the full tax burden.

Proposed Solution: The Small Business Tax Fairness and Compliance Simplification Act

To address this inequity, lawmakers have introduced the Small Business Tax Fairness and Compliance Simplification Act. This bipartisan legislation aims to extend the same tax credit available to restaurants to the beauty industry. Key features of the proposed act include:

• Equal Tax Treatment: Placing hair salons and barbershops on the same footing as restaurants regarding FICA taxes on tips.
• Bipartisan Support: Gaining backing from both Democratic and Republican lawmakers, reflecting widespread recognition of the issue.
• Economic Boost: Allowing small businesses to reinvest in their operations, leading to job creation and community development.

How This Change Would Benefit Small Businesses

Implementing this act would have several positive outcomes:

• Financial Relief: Reducing the tax burden allows businesses to allocate funds where they’re most needed.
• Employee Advancement: More resources could be directed toward employee training, benefits, and wages.
• Business Expansion: Freed-up capital can facilitate opening new locations or expanding services.
• Community Investment: Businesses can contribute more to local initiatives and charities.

Tips for Small Business Owners

While awaiting legislative changes, small business owners can take proactive steps to manage their tax obligations:

1. Stay Informed: Keep abreast of tax laws and proposed legislation that may affect your business.
2. Consult Tax Professionals: Work with accountants or tax advisors specializing in small business and tip income.
3. Implement Accurate Reporting Systems: Ensure all tips are accurately reported to minimize compliance issues.
4. Advocate for Change: Join industry associations or coalitions that lobby for fair tax treatment.
5. Educate Employees: Train staff on proper tip reporting and the impact of taxes on the business.

Calling on Lawmakers for Support

For meaningful change to occur, it’s crucial for lawmakers to understand the challenges faced by small businesses in the beauty industry. Business owners, employees, and patrons can:

• Reach Out to Representatives: Contact local senators and congresspeople to express support for the act.
• Share Personal Stories: Provide real-world examples of how the tax burden affects businesses and communities.
• Participate in Advocacy Groups: Join forces with organizations campaigning for tax fairness.
• Use Social Media Platforms: Leverage social networks to raise awareness and rally support.

The Broader Impact on the Beauty Industry

The beauty industry employs over one million people in the United States. With four out of five hair salons and barbershops being small businesses with fewer than ten employees, the proposed tax relief could have a substantial impact on:

• Job Creation: Enabling businesses to hire more staff and reduce unemployment.
• Economic Growth: Stimulating local economies through increased spending and investment.
• Industry Innovation: Allowing businesses to adopt new technologies and services.

Conclusion: Advocating for Fair Tax Policies

As new legislative sessions begin, there’s an opportunity for Congress to support small businesses by rectifying unfair tax policies. Passing the Small Business Tax Fairness and Compliance Simplification Act would not only benefit hair salons and barbershops but also strengthen the economy and communities they serve.

Final Thoughts and Encouragement

Small businesses are integral to the fabric of society, providing services, employment, and community engagement. By advocating for fair tax treatment, we support the growth and sustainability of these enterprises. Whether you’re a business owner, employee, or customer, your voice matters in pushing for equitable policies.

Take Action Today:

• Contact Your Lawmakers: Urge them to support the Small Business Tax Fairness and Compliance Simplification Act.
• Spread the Word: Share this information with others to build a collective movement for change.
• Support Local Businesses: Frequent your local hair salons and barbershops, and acknowledge their role in the community.

Together, we can work towards a fairer tax system that recognizes and supports the invaluable contributions of small businesses in the beauty industry.

Ready to work with us? Schedule a call today